Tuesday, May 31, 2011

. . . Cookie Time Tuesday . . .

Move over Little Debbie, there is a new Sheriff in town!  These cookies are Amazing!  I love Little Debbie Oatmeal Cream Pies but I will never think of them the same way again now that I've made these homemade Oatmeail Cream Pies.  The cookies so moist, soft and chewy then the cream is the perfect amount of sweetness.  I can just about guarantee these will be a hit.

Print Recipe Here
You will need:
1-¼ cup Butter, Softened
1 cup Light Brown Sugar, Packed
½ cups Granulated Sugar
1 whole Egg
2 teaspoons Vanilla Extract
1-½ cup Flour
1 teaspoon Baking Soda
½ teaspoons Salt
½ teaspoons Cinnamon
3 cups Quick Oats
For Filling:

½ cupsUnsalted Butter, Softened
1 teaspoon Vanilla Extract
2 cups Powdered Sugar
2 Tablespoons Milk
•  Gather Ingredients
• Beat butter and sugars until fluffy
• Combine the dry ingredients (except for Oatmeal)
• Slowly add flour mixture to butter mixture

•Add Oatmeal and mix well
• The dough is thick and easy to roll
• Roll into evenly sized balls or use a cookie scoop
• Bake for 11 minutes in a 375 degree oven

• Gather your ingredients for the filling
• Make sure the cookies are completely cooled
• Get ready to frost
• Frost the bottom of one cookie and place another cookie on top

• Look how soft and moist those look
• Once you've made a sandwich out of the cookies let them "dry"
• I left mine out for about an hour to let the frosting sort of harden up
• Serve and enjoy the compliments


  1. I was sitting around wondering how I could duplicate Fig Newtons and ran across this! Wow, these look dynamite!!! Cannot wait to try them! http://homesandbabies.blogspot.com

  2. Those look delightful. I too love oatmeal cream pies so I can imagine that these are even better.

  3. ahhh bookmarking this....

  4. Looks delish! Stopping by from the Sugarbeecrafts party. I would love for you to come link up to my party too, going on all week! Thanks


  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

  6. That looks awesome! I'm bookmarking this. Thanks a bunch for sharing. :-)

  7. Yummy! I am soo going to make these this weekend.


  8. omg, my husband would DIE of happiness if I made him these! :D They look so yummy! I can just imagine :D In fact, all of your goodies look so good!

  9. These are my husbands all-time favorite treat! Can't wait to make homemade ones! Found your blog on a link party and we are your newest followers!

    come check us out!

  10. Thank you to everyone for the nice comments. I think you will love making these and eating them :)

  11. Thanks for linking up, please remember to post my button in your post and/or on your blog. And be sure to enter my giveaway too going on until Sunday night =D Thanks!

  12. Love it!! I'll have to try these soon because they are my FAVORITE cookie!!! :)

  13. A homemade oatmeal cream pie - oh yum!! Where have you been all my life!

  14. Love your blog!! I am definitely going to be your new follower :) I would love it if you followed me to @ for-the-luv-of.blogspot.com that would be great :) I am just starting out, but I am excited to share new recipes, crafts, and makeup.. And Giving away giveaways on mineral make-up!


Thank you for stopping by to say "Hi". I love getting your comments.

If you like my what you see here I'd love for you to become a {Follower} so you can join in on the fun. Also join me on Facebook and Instagram!